Is Your Airbnb Rating Good? Compare It to Your Own Market

In Asheville, 87% of listings clear the 4.8 Superhost line. In Barcelona, 33% do. A rating only means something next to the market it competes in.

Free · no signup · nothing leaves your browser

Enter your rating, your review count and your city. You will get where you stand against the 4.8 line, exactly what it would take to be above it on the next assessment date, and how your margin compares to real listings in your own market.

Why your own market is the only fair comparison

"Is 4.8 good?" has no general answer, and the usual advice to compare yourself to a global average actively misleads. We measured 871,667 listings across 123 cities for the Superhost fragility study, and the gap between markets is larger than most hosts would guess.

The two columns measure different things, and a market can be hard on one and kind on the other. Copenhagen is unusually easy to qualify in and unusually precarious once you have: nearly three quarters of listings clear the line, and two thirds of those would lose it on one bad review. Asheville is comfortable on both counts. The tool above uses the figures for whichever of 119 markets you pick.

The thing most hosts get backwards

Faced with a thin margin, the instinct is to chase a higher rating. The arithmetic says to chase more reviews instead.

A listing with 15 reviews drops below 4.8 on a single 1-star review even if every review so far has been a 5. No rating saves it, because fifteen 5s plus one 1 is 4.75. The same flawless listing with 300 reviews could absorb fifteen 1-star reviews before dropping under.

Margin is bought with volume. A host who asks every departing guest for a review is protected in a way that a host with a spotless but small record simply is not. That is also why new listings feel so fragile: they are.

Why there is no probability here

The obvious version of this tool shows a percentage: your chance of still being above 4.8 on the assessment date. We built that, measured it, and took it out.

Any honest projection has to assume your future reviews look something like your past ones. But that assumption forces the answer: your average converges to the average you already have. Tested across three time horizons, a host below 4.8 came out at 0% every time and a host above it at 99%, no matter their review rate or how long was left. The percentage was a restatement of the current rating wearing more impressive clothes.

So the tool gives you the exact number of 5-star reviews you need and the monthly pace that implies. That is a real answer, it is arithmetic rather than a guess, and you can act on it.

Frequently asked questions

Is my Airbnb rating good compared to other hosts?

It depends entirely on your market, and the spread is enormous. In Asheville 87.1% of listings clear 4.8, while in Barcelona only 33.1% do. The same 4.8 rating puts you in the bottom half of one market and comfortably ahead in the other, so comparing yourself to a global average tells you very little about how you are actually doing where you operate.

What is the average Airbnb rating?

Across 871,667 listings with at least 10 reviews, 62.1% have an all-time rating of 4.8 or above and 37.3% reach 4.9. Ratings cluster very high, which is exactly why small differences matter so much: at the top of the scale a single bad review moves you further than a good one can.

What is a good review buffer on Airbnb?

Your buffer is how many 1-star reviews you could absorb before dropping below 4.8. Worldwide, 44% of listings above the line have a buffer of zero, so one bad review would cost them eligibility. A buffer of three or more is comfortable. The fastest way to grow it is more reviews rather than a higher rating, because buffer scales with volume.

Why does having more reviews protect your rating?

Because each new review moves the average less when there are more of them. A listing with 15 reviews falls below 4.8 on a single 1-star review even if every review so far has been a 5, since 15 fives plus one one is 4.75. The same flawless listing with 300 reviews could absorb 15 of them. Volume, not rating alone, is what buys you margin.

Does a 4-star review hurt your Superhost status?

Yes, if you are close to the line. Anything below 4.8 pulls your average down, and a 4-star review is below 4.8. For a host sitting at 4.81 with a modest review count, a single 4-star review can be enough to drop them under, which is why hosts are often surprised by a review they thought was positive.

Why do you not show a probability of keeping Superhost?

Because we tested one and it carried no information. Any honest projection has to assume your future reviews resemble your past ones, which means your average converges to the average you already have. A host below 4.8 came out at 0% at every time horizon and a host above it at 99%, regardless of circumstances. We would rather show you the exact number of 5-star reviews you need, which is a real answer you can act on.

How this was built

The threshold arithmetic is closed form rather than simulated, so every figure is exact for the numbers you enter. It runs against the same engine that powers our paid product, and the browser and server versions are checked against each other on every change so they cannot drift apart.

The market figures come from Inside Airbnb's public datasets under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence. Our own results are published under the same licence as machine-readable data, so anything here can be checked rather than taken on trust.